Artist Review: MrJimmyDaFloof

Artist Name: Jim / Roland / MrJimmaDaFloof
Pronouns: He/Him
Instagram: mrjimmydafloofs
Twitter: @MrJimmyDaFloof
FurAffinity: JamesMiller


Commission by MrJimmyDaFloof


Jimmy was an artist I’d seen around twitter for a while before I finally got an opportunity to commission them. I had instantly fallen in love with their style and textures. I knew they’d be the perfect match to draw this illustration. He got it exactly as I had imagined.

Section 1 – Communication

Jimmy does an excellent job of keeping up with his clients. He maintains a public Trello Queue for customers and potential clients to see his workload. In my experience, the best way to reach out to him is via Telegram or Twitter.

Trello was updated routinely and accurately. Delays, if any, are communicated via public twitter posts as well as Telegram Channels.

Jimmy does maintain a price sheet. At the of this writing I was unable to locate a public one, however. This could be due to him re-working his prices or not currently being open for new work at the time of this entry. I do know that when he lists his openings, the price sheet is included along with a copy of his terms of service. On his FA page he does encourage people to reach out to him at any time for a copy of current prices or to discuss a project for future openings.

Commissions are not on a “first come, first served” basis. When openings are announced, you’ll be directed to a Google Docs Form to submit your request. These are reviewed and those who are selected are contacted. SFW and NSFW openings are handled separately for those of you who wish to keep the more… adult parts of furry of your screens.

In my case, prices and estimates were provided in USD. Payment is accepted via paypal invoice only.

Communication Star Rating: 5/5

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Communication 1.5 (Price Availability) Star Rating: 4.5/5

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

Section 2 – Price/Value

NOTE: As always, I’ll point out that prices are subjective. What may come across as overpriced for one person another may call undervalued. This section is not for saying what I believe the artist should have charged. Prices are subject to change as artist’s are always reevaluating what they charge for their work.

I found Jimmy’s prices to be extremely on par with the quality of his work. When I commissioned him in June 2022, I was quoted and paid $370.00 for the image above; a 2 character, full render with background. Extremely reasonable for the finished product.

Price/Value Rating: 5/5

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Section 3 – Time

The only time I have commissioned this artist I did not set a deadline. Jimmy’s TOS allows for deadlines to be negotiated prior to payment being submitted.

Jimmy accepts batches of commissions at a time. Numbers vary based on the complexity of the orders. In my case, my commission was accepted and paid for on June 14th, 2022. On July 5th, 2022 I received a sketch/draft. It had sat in my junk folder for a little bit because I’m dumb. Luckily I noticed the update on his Trello and checked! I received the finished version in early August, the exact date escapes me.

Given the type of commission I requested and the listed workload on the Trello at the time this turnaround time was actually surprising to me. I expected to wait until the end of August, early September.

Time Rating: 5/5

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Section 4 – Final Product

My overall experience with commissioning Jimmy has been excellent. From the first time I reached out in April of 2022 to inquire about a price list and a possible ETA as to when he would be open for more work so that I could make sure I got mine submitted in time, to the final product hitting my inbox he was an absolute pleasure to work with.

With his form I submitted a written version of what I was looking for as well as reference sheets for both characters, the style of clothes I wanted them to have on, and a Google Street View screenshot to show the type of background I was looking for. This was one of those rare cases where I actually had a specific idea in mind.

Given that I was introducing a character who would be a demon with powers on-par with a God, I wanted something that would kinda hint that there was more to him than at a glance.

So I asked Jimmy to draw them at the corner of First Street and Amistad Road with Oslo finishing up a cigarette. I wanted a city background complete with the steel metro supports to really drive the feeling home. He seriously knocked it out of the park.

If you can figure out what song I pulled my inspiration from, you get a cookie.

Usually I’d try and post all of that here, but it appears I’ve lost some of that data along the way. I think I may have accidentally dumped the email chain at some point. Derp. So here’s what I’ve been able to recover!

Final Product Rating: 5/5

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Section 5 – Final Scores and Summary

From start to finish, working with Jimmy to bring these two characters to life was an absolute pleasure. His submission form was easy to fill out, the TOS was clear and easy to understand. At no time did I not feel like I didn’t know where I was in his queue.

The only knock I can really give him is that I couldn’t locate a current price list for him; and while I didn’t see anything about it being updated, I imagine that may be the case. Extremely minor when you factor in everything else!

He did an excellent job and I’d gladly commission him again!

Communication

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Communication 1.5

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

Price/Value

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Time

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Final Product

Rating: 5 out of 5.

FINAL SCORE

Rating: 5 out of 5.

(4.9/5)

Artist Review: Manex57

Artist Name: Manex57
Pronouns: She/Her
Website: https://manex57.com/
Twitter: @57Manex
Patreon: Manex57


My Characters by Manex57
(SFW Only on this Site)


I honestly can’t remember how I came across their FA page; but I’m glad I did. Manex57 has quickly become one of my favorite artists to work with and someone I point to as an example of what I consider a professional artist.

Section 1 – Communication

Manex57 does an awesome job of communicating with her customers. She maintains a public Trello Queue so that customers can find out their commission status at a glance. Commission communications are largely handled by Telegram chat, but you can also reach them via FA Note or Twitter.

I’ve found the Trello to be updated at least daily. Updates are accurate and reflect the current status of your commission. “Delays” are communicated to the customer when they occur. Should know, I put “delays” in quotes here because the only time I’ve run into a delay with this artist, it was based on her personal deadline and not any that I had set. Quite appreciated!

Manex’s price list is readily available on their twitter (pinned post), their FA or their own webpage. Being based in England, prices are listed in British Pounds/Pound Sterling. Base prices are available, with an option to contact the artist for a quote for anything not listed.

WIP sketches were provided every step of the way and each time I was given an opportunity to approve it before moving forward.

This artist also takes on Kigurumi commissions, the prices of which are readily available on their website. I haven’t commissioned one of these myself (yet).

Communication Star Rating: 5/5

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Communication 1.5 (Price Availability) Star Rating: 5/5

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Section 2 – Price/Value

As always, I’ll point out that prices are subjective. What may come across as overpriced for one person another may call undervalued. This section is not for saying what I believe the artist should have charged. Prices are subject to change as artist’s are always reevaluating what they charge for their work.

I’ve found Manex’s prices to be pretty fair, and even a bit cheaper than I expected. Payments are made via Paypal Invoice. Invoices are clear and easy to read. They list what exactly you ordered and any options you choose.

In my case, I’ve placed a few orders with this artist.

For a 2 character, full body commissions with shading, simple background, and clothing: the total charged was £110.00 ($137.12 USD*). Less than I expected to pay. For a single character, full body, with shading and clothing the total charge was £40.00 ($49.86 USD*). For a pack of Telegram stickers I was charged £20.00 ($24.93*). All extremely good prices.

NOTE: This information is based off paypal invoices. The artist may have changed their prices since that time. Always consul the artist’s most recent pricelist for what you’ll expect to pay.

*does not include paypal exchange rate or paypal fees associated with currency conversion.

Price/Value Rating: 5/5

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Section 3 – Time

To date, I haven’t set a deadline for any of the commissions I’ve had from this artist. Turnaround times have been extremely fast and acceptable. The longest amount of time I’ve had to wait for a commission to be completed with a little over 2.5 weeks, and this was during the holidays.

Should note that completion time is always a huge variable and a lot of factors go into just how long you may have to wait. Your milage may vary.

I haven’t ordered a Kigurumi from this artist, so I can’t speak to wait times for those. However, I haven’t seen anyone complain about their wait times. If you plan to commission them for one of these, always factor shipping times into how long you expect to wait. The artist has no control over how long it takes the shipper to lose your package, find it again, then send it to the wrong facility fives times before finally marking it out for delivery.

Time Rating: 5/5

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Section 4 – Final Product

In each case, Manex57 has delivered a completed commission that has exceeded my expectations. She was the first artist to draw my character Oslo and she did an amazing job capturing his personality and style.

Character designs and colors have always been excellent, including clothing and accessories. Each time, I had provided the artist with a character reference sheet, a description of what I was looking for, and references for anything clothing or accessories.

(click the arrows to scroll from ref sheet, to order, to finished product)

Each commission since that time, whether being custom work or a YCH, has been completed in excellent fashion.

All commissions were provided to me upon completion via Telegram; and all of them have been as agreed and described. To date, I’ve yet to run into any errors with anything they’ve created for me; though given how professional they are I doubt they would hesitate to fix them providing they were notified in a timely manner.

Final Product Rating: 5/5

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Section 5 – Final Scores and Summary

All in all, my experience commission Manex has been absolutely amazing. From the first contact to my most recent order, she’s always delivered and been awesome to work with. I recommend her every chance I get!

With everything factored in I am pleased to give Manex57 a perfect score and the official #WolfApproved seal.

Communication

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Communication 1.5

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Price/Value

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Time

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Final Product

Rating: 5 out of 5.

FINAL SCORE

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Artist Reviews

So I’m going to start doing something I’ve been thinking of doing for a while. I’ve commissioned a fair amount of artists over the years (and still do). Some of them have been great, some of them have been… less so.

These reviews will be strictly based on my own, personal experience. As always, your milage may vary.

Each review will be centered around the following criteria:

  1. Communication
  2. Price/Value
  3. Time
  4. Final Product
  5. Final Score, Summary

Each will be graded on a scale of 1 (low) to 5 (high), with the final score being averaged out.

1. Communication

Commission is the foundation of every commission process. So of course it reasons that it should be the foundation of a commission review. This section will focus around the following:

  1. Are communications clear and understood?
  2. How often does the artist provide updates? (Direct, via Trello, List, etc)
  3. Are delays communicated clearly?
  4. Are WIPs provided (if applicable)?
  5. Is the artist’s price list easy to find and read?*
  6. How easy is the artist to get ahold of?*

(* These two sections will be graded together, seperate from the overall communications score. This score will appear as “Section 1.5”)

2. Price/Value

This one is kinda hard to grade, but I’ll give it a good college try. Prices are subjective, what one person considers overpriced someone else will call fair value or too cheap. To score this, I’ll weigh the price paid versus the quality of the finished work, if it lines up with other similar works by the same artist, and if the product was delivered as agreed.

This section will not be used to discuss what the artist should have charged.

3. Time

This category is kinda self explanatory, but;

  1. What was the estimated completion date for the commission (if any)?
  2. Was a deadline set for the commission?
  3. If so, was the deadline met? Completed early? Arrived late?
  4. How many days, weeks, months or years did it take to get the commission?

4. Final Product

Of course, the most important of all the categories, the final product.

  1. Was the commission completed?
  2. Was the commission provided to the customer?
  3. Was the commission as agreed/described?
  4. If there was any errors, were they resolved?

5. Final Score and Summary

The final score will be calculated by combining all categories and dividing by 5.
(1 + 1.5 + 2 + 3 + 4 = X / 5 = Final)